Top eleven survey v2

Hi friends,
I am back with another survey.Anyways I did'nt got much support in first one'lets hope this time.

Survey question:Special ability adds special skills to player.If we want to relate special abilities with each other,then can corner kick specialist prove to be nice FK taker?Can a dribbler be realted with one on soccer?Can shadow striker be realted with free kick ability or plenty kick ability?

Suppose if a team does not have required ability,Can other ability replace it?If it can then please answer in comment.

EXAMPLE:
Suppose a team have two strikers,one is young(18 yrs) and other is elder(30 yrs).If young one is one on one striker and elder is corner kick specialist.If we assume attacking skills of both players to be same.The who can be best free kick taker?
Did you got my question?I hope you understand my survey objective.

Best answer for survey question will be displayed here later given by you<<<here

Any answer guys?

I am sorry that I cannot help. This is an advance question that I have not studied at all. Moreover, I am not sure if I really understand the question. Good luck.

i think....maybe or maybe not....play maker maybe good at CK...at least it will show the logo out to mention him kick the ball if score.... and one-on-one stopper will show at PK...when the time he save it...

well...then.... i don't think...you can count anything related to FK....cause even FK skill will not score 100% (and this maybe lead back to CK...even CK skill will not make you score 10/10 times)...so how can you compare one-on-one & CK skill for a FK situation to see which one is better (or a play maker vs other skill in CK) ? because some skills also related to how strong you opposites are ....so...no data can be actually available ....

I think any player can do well from setpieces at any time, it's the frequency of success that separates quality players from average ones.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HoofDaddy

I think any player can do well from setpieces at any time, it's the frequency of success that separates quality players from average ones.

---

Idea ruled out!
Reason:Not relevant to survey.

No expert can answer this?

Yeah I was slightly OT. From my experience, I would say that CK specialists take better FKs than 1v1 players.

Do you believe at all in SA? What makes you think that they are not just visual? Because I play this game over 40 seasons and have not seen evidence that SA really work.

yes I've had many either footed MCs that went from being unable to score to scoring 1 FK in every 2 games. If the opponent has 2 Dwall SAs though, its a Q battle. SAs on opposing teams cancel each other out a lot, but I'd rather have and hope then have not and wonder.

Your question is coming from a bad angle. Is pointless to say like this because abilities are not related between them like you assumed that might be.

But like an answer, yes it can but not because of the special ability but just simply by his stats and that's all.

Also despite the abilities looks like something permanent they are not, they are just something temporarily during the game and they only activate when you are in a specific situation.

Defensive wall - Against free kicks
Free kick taker - When you have free kicks
Penalty kick taker - At penalties

And so on :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by po_zdrach

Do you believe at all in SA? What makes you think that they are not just visual? Because I play this game over 40 seasons and have not seen evidence that SA really work.

---

They do work and you can see them in live match, when they activate you see over a player an icon that represent his specific special ability.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PricopGeorgeCătălin

They do work and you can see them in live match, when they activate you see over a player an icon that represent his specific special ability.

---

First of all I have to say that I wanted to belive in SA and I liked them, but last season I had a game for the Cup, which i lost with penalties. My players missed 2 penaltues from 5. The two players that missed the penalties was the the only one with SA penalty kicks specialist. One of them was bought from the scout list and the other from the auction (nordgen) both of the players are good with high raiting.

So, I think that when SA activate in live match it is just visual effect... Unfortunately!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by po_zdrach

First of all I have to say that I wanted to belive in SA and I liked them, but last season I had a game for the Cup, which i lost with penalties. My players missed 2 penaltues from 5. The two players that missed the penalties was the the only one with SA penalty kicks specialist. One of them was bought from the scout list and the other from the auction (nordgen) both of the players are good with high raiting.

So, I think that when SA activate in live match it is just visual effect... Unfortunately!

---

Agreed! The idea and visual is great. The reel effect is sadly absent

IMO SA work with right players and on the proper positions, all my team has SA and I try to explore that a lot shadow striker always score from long range, free kick taker usually scores, corner kick works well and on defense only aerial and defense wall, some people do put others SA for defenders but I think it's a waste and for me even dmc should only defend, the only ones I don't like much is dribler, and playmaker I think they don't work att all. ( copied from a previous post).