At a complete loss as to what happened...

[ChelmsfordFC]

Well I've been playing Top Eleven now since the beginning of March, having ups and downs, Lost the cup at the quarter finals to a weaker team, and just now lost the Champions League at the quarter finals to yet again a weaker team. I'm at a complete loss as to what is going on.

It's not due to condition or morale, as I completely maxed out both of them before the match started.

I beat the opponent 2-0 on the home game in the champions league, and have been defeated quite embarresingly 3-0 on the away game. Pictures below to show that I still had posession bonus of 7%, all my team bonuses were maxed out, and my team is of higher quality than his. So what is going on?

Neither of our formations changed, so I would assume that I should get the same outcome as before. Or at least, that's what makes sense to me.

My teams quality is 96%, their team quality is 87%. Should also mention that "Reale" is also a scout level striker.