when i browse the transfer market, i often see players like these:





one of them with a good overall rating, the other one with a great defence rating, but bad attack and physical. ignoring age, who is the better player here? i would think the second one?


i guess for keepers attack is almost useless? for defenders i guess its also not very important. and for strikers i guess defence is not important?
and midfielders need both, cause the need to do both jobs to a certain extent?