You don't need 8*-9* players.
Two 7* AML - AMR are ok.

As I've learned from my experience if you play with defensive formations with counter attacks you can't lose.
no, wrong. Not always.
Both teams create very few chances and shots on target so the winner may comes by luck.
If it doesn't work, then switch to attack - no counters, high pres, mtm, maybe hard tackling, maybe off-side.