My little whine...

How is this possible...I took a screen little late but players are still in position...my player dribbled GK and he was at goal line...free goal but no he passes to guy few cms away...(there are 2 of my players on goal line where ball is)

But well that doesnt matter as much as a fact that there were no offside and this is 2nd time happening...

Offside is when player passes to a player among last and second last enemy player not if 2 or more players are in that position or if player is last player behind all opponents...
Nordeus needs to learn football rules :D

Is not really a whine tho...but funny situation...and some stuff for topeleven programers to fix in video...

Attachment 108486

T11 has no VAR yet :D

You are the one who doesn’t know the rules. This is offside. Nevertheless a quite strange situation, never happening in real football.

If 2 players pass to each other and they are both between last and 2nd last player is not an offside...
Offside would be if passer would be behind whole enemy team or behind 2nd last player and pass to a guy who is between last and 2nd last player...

Happend to me once again later on the day...
If I am mistaken please enlighten me...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Guido van den Berg

You are the one who doesn’t know the rules. This is offside. Nevertheless a quite strange situation, never happening in real football.

---

it has to be a forward pass to be offside, it would be hard pushed to forward pass on the goal line, but I suppose possible, if measuring in millimetres, I think the bigger question is why would a pass occur there in the 1st place

Well cuz is nordeus we are talking about :D
Happend again little later in event progression vs other opponent another weird offside I cant aknowledge as one
If you watch matches you will see some weird offsides :D
Is probably just error in video...offside action is showed as nooffside action or I got it totally wrong but I doubt it tho..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mitja fc

If 2 players pass to each other and they are both between last and 2nd last player is not an offside...
Offside would be if passer would be behind whole enemy team or behind 2nd last player and pass to a guy who is between last and 2nd last player...

Happend to me once again later on the day...
If I am mistaken please enlighten me...

---

As I wrote before, you are mistaken. The offside rule is quite straightforward. With every forward pass, there should be at least two players (goalkeeper and a field player, or two field payers) between the receiving player and the goal line at the moment the pass is given. The position of the passing player is relevant relative to the receiving player only (receiving player should be closer to the goal line). The position of the passing payer relative to the opponent players is not relevant.

I really feel like this guy in the pub, trying to explain the offside rule to his girlfriend using glasses of beer. You need so many words to explain something so obvious...

Guys stop discussing about it because is a known issue, where simply don't fit the offside with the video animation in few cases, this is a rare issue, but exists since the live animations were implemented. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by khris

Guys stop discussing about it because is a known issue, where simply don't fit the offside with the video animation in few cases, this is a rare issue, but exists since the live animations were implemented. :)

---

known issue since 2016 :rolleyes:

here it is 2016 & 2017 edition
https://forum.topeleven.com/top-elev...tml#post470478

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Guido van den Berg

As I wrote before, you are mistaken. The offside rule is quite straightforward. With every forward pass, there should be at least two players (goalkeeper and a field player, or two field payers) between the receiving player and the goal line at the moment the pass is given. The position of the passing player is relevant relative to the receiving player only (receiving player should be closer to the goal line). The position of the passing payer relative to the opponent players is not relevant.

I really feel like this guy in the pub, trying to explain the offside rule to his girlfriend using glasses of beer. You need so many words to explain something so obvious...

---

Dude you are just half right...aka mistaken
If reciver is in front of all enemy team is not an offside it never was also if passer and reciver are in so called "offside line" together is not an offside...offside is when reciver is in line where only 1 enemy player is between him and goal line and he recive a forward pass from a player who isnt in same line

So please do not try to explain offside rule to a girl in a pub cuz you might not score...

Jesus...

Dude, you are really annoying. I googled “offside” for you, so you can check for yourself. It is really not that complicated.

https://www.fifa.com/mm/document/afd...w%2011_554.pdf

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mitja fc

If 2 players pass to each other and they are both between last and 2nd last player is not an offside...
Offside would be if passer would be behind whole enemy team or behind 2nd last player and pass to a guy who is between last and 2nd last player...

Happend to me once again later on the day...
If I am mistaken please enlighten me...

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Guido van den Berg

Dude, you are really annoying. I googled “offside” for you, so you can check for yourself. It is really not that complicated.

https://www.fifa.com/mm/document/afd...w%2011_554.pdf

---

Is the 2nd player next to the rival area (usually theres the GK, and then the 2nd player is a defender, but it doesn't matter if the GK is advanced and the 2 players more next to the goal are 2 defenders)
Who "marks the offside" not the last.

Attachment 108586


Attachment 108588

The "2nd player is the limit" always.

And then, again, the game have a fail doing a synchro between the comments and the offsides, we know it. Always existed since the live animations were introduced, and it is not easy to fix.

I bet that in your case the GK marks the line, as you've 2 players between him and the last player. If thats the case, the offside line belongs as mentioned to the GK.

Then,
If the Nº 1 overcame the GK, and did a passing to the 17, and the nº 17 did a passing again to the 1, is offside as both are between the last defender and the GK who marks the offside line.

Yeah, it is stupid cause in a case like this areal player would shoot.


Attachment 108590
**the red line should be not in front the GK, should be behind as is the foot more net to the own Goal what determines the line, but Ive set it here for space reasons lol