It is a tough call no matter what. I like the short passing on the 1-1 up the middle though.
I just played that formation vs a 4-4-2 classic and dominated possession, and this formation he is up against is a bit more defensive 3-5-2, and can be treated as a 3-4-1-2.
Anyways, you cant miss with playing either. Well the NGE can have a say, but I think the formation should win.