A 1* player? does he even have enough quality to actually be considered 1* at your level, because there is still inactives everywhere, even at L8, My Troll City league has teams with 1* players in them.
Don't forget there is also a good chance I won't even win my league this season the way things are going with Batigo. He plays the 3rd place team away tomorrow but knowing our luck he will win with flying colours or a lucky goal.