I'd say theres a few ways of going out this.

4-5-1 Flat could be a possibily as with 3-5-2 flat or 3-5-2 V. Or you could go 'Mirror match' and go 4-5-1 V as well.

But my personal recommendation is 5-4-1...

-----ST-----
AML-----AMR
---MC-MC---
-------------
DL-DC-DC-DC-DR

His striker will struggle to get past a 5 man defensive and you wont exactly be short in attacking options with a formation set-up like that, You need Normal Mentality + Defensive with long balls and Counter-Attack, This should ensure you have sufficient attacks in the game whilst fending off his attacks.