The Myth of good and bad players

[nikolgiorgos]

I just post it to show that there isn't a good GK in TE.
Good GK who makes many saves, means you have a weak team

[Tactician]

I just post it to show that there isn't a good GK in TE.
Good GK who makes many saves, means you have a weak team

I did have a good GK before but later in his career he became ****, but the most of the team became **** at that time, so don't know what happened. In his early career, he was very active, making super and great saves, including in associations. At that time, I did not have a weak team, and in fact, I had one of my all time best teams. He was the best GK I ever had . For me, what defines a good GK is his activity with respect to number of shots on target. I mean, you can feel he is present, not like some loose hole that is half asleep between the posts. A good GK will step up and do man of the match performances if required, and he will make the difference in tight matches.

All that being said, even the best players have some bad days, but on overall, based on performance relative to quality, they clearly better and also consistent.

[milpol]

I just post it to show that there isn't a good GK in TE.
Good GK who makes many saves, means you have a weak team

No, not exactly. My gk ,oblak makes great saves. Whatever you can imagine. Ina single match he saved a counter attack, a corner kick and a free kick(with that flick).

He is really good gk but not the best definitely. In my opinion it's up to his characteristics.no best gk in top eleven. You can have a 8* defence and a 6* gk and still get the most clean sheets as podrinje did when he won the competion here

[Tactician]

No, not exactly. My gk ,oblak makes great saves. Whatever you can imagine. Ina single match he saved a counter attack, a corner kick and a free kick(with that flick).

He is really good gk but not the best definitely. In my opinion it's up to his characteristics.no best gk in top eleven. You can have a 8* defence and a 6* gk and still get the most clean sheets as podrinje did when he won the competion here

Yeah, this is the difference between good and bad GKs. Good ones will makes saves when required and will make the difference in tight situations while the bad ones will be mostly loose, conceeding easy goals or even passing the ball back to the opponent, except when the game is trolling the opponent where even ****ty GKs will appear unbeatable. But, finding one is hard. I bought a 21 y.o yesterday as I was not satisfied with other 2 GK my team and I was willing to try something different. The new GK got 1 MoM from 2 matches played where in both matches he saved all the shots on target (2 and 2). So, I can say that he is better than the other two.


But still, things are not sure because I feel that the game engine is full of tricks, and also I feel that certain things are broken as they do not seem to function properly or as expected.

[nikolgiorgos]

No, not exactly. My gk ,oblak makes great saves. Whatever you can imagine. Ina single match he saved a counter attack, a corner kick and a free kick(with that flick).
He is really good gk but not the best definitely. In my opinion it's up to his characteristics.no best gk in top eleven. You can have a 8* defence and a 6* gk and still get the most clean sheets as podrinje did when he won the competion here

Don't know, maybe we have a different perception but when I 'm saying Good player I mean something special, something to remember, to put it in the hall of fame of your team.

For example your GK has avg rate less than 8, 9/16 clean sheets, 1 motm title in 16 games.
A GK with high q and semi-mutant skills.
I believe if you had a simple GK with some 110% with more balance skills and without sa, he could have the same stats.

* Now about we see in Live animations, maybe it's from a parallel universe - lol