Narrow diamond vs Narrow diamond (4-1-2-1-2)

[camoka]

Hello all,
in order to test narrow diamond I've played with an opponent with narrow diamond formation and I lost again.
It was a cup match. For the first match (home) I've played 4-1-3n-1-1 and lost 1-4 to narrow diamond (My team was +2 better in quality) For the second match (away) I've changed the formation to narrow diamond the opponent was also narrow diamond and I lost 2-1.
here is the stats:
Level:5
My teams quality = average 43
Opponents quality = average 38 or 39
Match stats
Possesion opponent=%46 my team=%54
Total shots opponent=16 my team=12
Shots on target opponent=9 my team=6
Passes completed opponent=83 my team=80
free kicks opponent=3 my team =1
corners opponent=5 my team=2
saves opponent=0 my team=3
tacles opponent=19 my team=22
fouls opponent=8 my team 14
no red card
no injury
no opponent substitution

my orders= attacking, through the middle, whole pitch, normal, short zonal
I have one play maker in my team, he/she has one on one stopper as GK and free kick specialist
no arrows in my team for the first half (1-0) and tried full red arrows in second half (2-1)

I figured out that the opponent has not checked the counter attack, no hard tackling, don't know about others.
All my players %90 or more moral and condition

do you have any suggestion about what can I do better?
thank you