Table of Counter Formations - What to use?

[Hobbit71]

hi everybody!

today i have to beat a 4-3W-1-2 and found the counter 4-1-4-1 at this forum

for tactics I selected:
mentality: defensive
focus passing. through the middle
pressing style : whole opitch
tackling style: normal
passing style: short
force counterattacks: x
play offsied trap: x

could this be the right way against a strong opponent???

thanks for your help!

so, the game is over and I lost 0:3.
certainly the possession was 50:50
i think, a second striker was missing.

any ideas for the second leg??

[SSDD]

so, the game is over and I lost 0:3.
certainly the possession was 50:50
i think, a second striker was missing.

any ideas for the second leg??

Well, too bad I didn't read your post earlier.
Counter-attacking tactics and short passing (especially through the middle) are like Millwall and West Ham fans. With 4-1-4-1 your orders shoud've been something like this:
normal/defensive mentality
passing- mixed/down both flanks
pressing- own half
tackling- normal
passes-mixed/long
marking-zonal
I don't like the "force counter" order and absolutely hate the "offside trap" one, so I don't use them.
For the re-match you shoud use a more attacking setup, like the 3-1-4-2, attacking mentality, mixed passing, pressing- whole pitch, hard tackling, mixed passes, zonal marking and only if your CD's are quick- offside trap!

[Marcio David]

-----st-----
-amc--amc-
--mc---mc---
----dmc----
dl-dc-dc-dr