I think it will be illegal due to three players on the right side, you'll just need minimal defence placed well to deal with his attackers on the rare chances they have to get forward.
----------ST-----------
AML-----------------AMR
ML---MC-------MC---MR
-------------------------
------DC--DC--DC-------
This is what I've come up with, it's odd but players are placed to triple mark all his attacking players while giving you a strong attack down the wings, only his MC is only double marked. You're free to rearrange them slightly.
Attacking/hard attacking, down both flanks, own half/whole pitch, normal tackling, mixed passing, zonal marking. No counter, no offsides. Red arrows on all four wingers, blue arrows on MCs if you feel they are needed.
How do the teams compare btw?