How would you play against a 3-1-4-2 ?

-----ST----ST----
ML-MC-----MC-MR
-------DMC-------
----DC-DC-DC----

My oponent is a hard one, the first in my league, and his squad has all 4 stars and 5 stars, and he is local.

My team is only 3 star and few 4 star.

First time i played against him it was a 1-1 tie, but I was local, I used:


--------ST-------
AML----------AMR
----MC----MC----
-------DMC-------
DL-DC------DC-DR