You should try the 4-1-3-2 formation. With this formation your DMC will cancel out his AMC, your MC's will win the midfield battle and your two ST's will take advantage of his three wide defenders. Make sure you put red arrows on your DL and DR as you'll be using a counterattacking formation.

Orders:

Team Mentality - Defensive
Focus Passing - Though the middle
Pressing Style - Own Half
Tackling Style - Hard
Passing Style - Long
Marking Style - Zonal

Force counterattacks & no offside trap.

Good luck and post your result later!