he 's probably playing with red arrows to his MR , ML or with flanks or both.
Put your best DL, DR playing with blue arrows.
I would try also a 4-5-1 V, def, counters, flanks, blue arrows to my def, red arrows to my wingers
maybe man-to-man, maybe long pass.
If the game doesn't go well, after the brake, then trying a 4-4-2 ND (if you have a AMC-AMR or AMC-AML), and through the middle this time.