Hi, I would try with 4-5-1 vstyle, 3n-3w-2-1-1 or 4-1-2-1-2 narrow diamond, according to your team qualities.
Defensive/High defensive ,counter on,mixed/short pass
4-5-1 v-style : mixed target, red arrows on aml,amr and st
3n-3w-2-1-1 : mixed target ,red arrows on dml,dmr,amc and st
4-1-2-1-2 : center target, red arrows on dl,dr,amc and 2st
Do not use blue arrows when playing defensive or high defensive,
otherwise you allow your opponents to score easier.
Do not use red arrow on dmc if opponent uses amc (as in your situation),
if st often go offside, try removing red arrows.