Have not seen this formation before: 4-2N-2W-0-2

[cracicot]

-------ST--ST------
---------------------
-ML--------------MR-
-----DMC--DMC----
-DL---DC---DC---DR-

Is like a more defensive hexagon.

I was thinking of the 3-2-2-2-1 butterfly as this would create a battle on the wings.

--------ST----------
-AML-----------AMR-
------MC--MC-------
-DML-----------DMR-
-----DC-DC-DC------

My 3 DC should counter his 2 ST.
My DML/DMR should counter his ML/MR with red arrows with help from my 2 MCs.
My 2 MCs should have the run of the midfield and with 6 total midfielders for me, I should dominate possession.
Set long ball on the flanks and hope I get some crosses in: he has no Defense with SA, which is good.

OR

Do I go with 3-5-2 flat with motivated wingers?

------ST---ST-------
---------------------
-ML--MC-MC-MC--MR-
--------------------
------DC-DC-DC------

OR

------ST---ST-------
-AML------------AMR-
-----MC-MC-MC-----
--------------------
-----DC-DC-DC------

Any opinions or advice would be appreciated.

[Narf]

I don't think that he would be attacking through the middle and you'll need to get a lot of attacking power here, so I'd try adding another striker at the expense of an MC.

------ST----ST------
AML------------AMR
---------MC---------
DML------------DMR
----DC--DC--DC----

... with red on the AMs and blue on DMs and all three DCs (as you'll be pushing and he'll be hoping on counter-attacks, so you need your full-backs to stay on guard). You could use ML and MR if you're concerned about possession, but I think you'll rule it anyway.

[xiaosian]

-------ST--ST------
---------------------
-ML--------------MR-
-----DMC--DMC----
-DL---DC---DC---DR-

Is like a more defensive hexagon.

I was thinking of the 3-2-2-2-1 butterfly as this would create a battle on the wings.

--------ST----------
-AML-----------AMR-
------MC--MC-------
-DML-----------DMR-
-----DC-DC-DC------

My 3 DC should counter his 2 ST.
My DML/DMR should counter his ML/MR with red arrows with help from my 2 MCs.
My 2 MCs should have the run of the midfield and with 6 total midfielders for me, I should dominate possession.
Set long ball on the flanks and hope I get some crosses in: he has no Defense with SA, which is good.

OR

Do I go with 3-5-2 flat with motivated wingers?

------ST---ST-------
---------------------
-ML--MC-MC-MC--MR-
--------------------
------DC-DC-DC------

OR

------ST---ST-------
-AML------------AMR-
-----MC-MC-MC-----
--------------------
-----DC-DC-DC------

Any opinions or advice would be appreciated.

try 4-4-2 , mayb it work for you

[Master Tactician]

He'll definitely try to attack with wingers. Does he have good full backs?
I like the idea of 3-2-2-2-1 butterfly. I would motivate DMLs/DMRs with red arrows too, in order to put some width to your team and to create situations where you will outnumber him. That way, they'll defend against his MR/ML and they'll move forward when you attack.