Indeed your condition and moral has to be full.
And indeed again it depends on your opponent's formation.

4-4-2 (sometimes 4-4-1-1) works fine for me.
Hard attacking, down both flanks, whole pitch, hard, short, zonal, play offside trap.
All condition and moral full or for 80-90%.
As I said this works fine for ME.

But I hope you can fix this problem, I wish you good luck