Well I opted to play my in form keeper. I played highly offensive (away leg of the cup, needed to win by atleast and score 2 goals) and left him with only 3 defenders. Won the game against the higher skilled team 3-1, 8 match rating. I had a game 30 minutes later and played my out of form keeper. The team was of lower quality. He made the first mistake I've seen a goalie make on this game. Managed to botch a clearance, they scored on the following corner. We still won 3-1 but he had a 5/10 rating and he is now on the transfer market.