illegal formation vs illegal formation, what will happen? lol

[July Fourth]

I'm the big loser lol, turns out it was NOT an illegal formation!

I don't understand why one team had 20-80 punishment when both formations shown was illegal, when I tested this a long time ago it worked out at 46-54.

[werewolf122]

I don't understand why one team had 20-80 punishment when both formations shown was illegal, when I tested this a long time ago it worked out at 46-54.

I tested recently. What you and dvr said is correct. If both play with illegal formations, the engine treats as non-illegal formations.

[Mr Mercury]

I tested recently. What you and dvr said is correct. If both play with illegal formations, the engine treats as non-illegal formations.

True.
But as KoH realised, an abandoned team with not enough players will (or could) be given players in positions to make a legal formation. So always beware of playing abandoned teams.

[tongly45]

True.
But as KoH realised, an abandoned team with not enough players will (or could) be given players in positions to make a legal formation. So always beware of playing abandoned teams.

nope. not enough player will be punished by 3-0 lost. abandonned team usually has 20% ball possession because they have many player out of his natural position not beacause his formation is illegal.
until he get 11 player to play (14 player inclus injured, cards) player will automatically fill in emty position to complete the last formation used before abandoning