One man's great suggestion is another man's reason for quitting. Even when it seems 'everyone agrees' it is usually very misleading, because the 'everyone' that you're talking about is usually:
a) Only the people who use the forum
b) Only the people who care about the issue enough to shout loudly on that particular thread and
c) Assumes that these people know what's good for the game, or even what factors contribute to their own enjoyment (this is a discussion in itself)
I have played literally dozens of MMRPGS in my time and have seen several take a significant turn for the worse when the devs made a change that 'everybody' asked for.