are players match ratings random?

[hod]

After my post yesterday ive now got another laugh that is my players match ratings.

I bought a scout player at the start of the season. He is a CM and ive only played him in his proper position and ive kept his condition and more up high and ive given him a good run in the team but, after 20 games his average rating is 5.0!!!

So today I was playing a far weaker team in the league and won 9-0 with my scout CM scoring 1 and assisting on 1 so I thought he must get a good rating today.....nope he gets a 6!!!! I had 4 sevens and 6 eights with my other players!!!!

Anybody got an explanation? I don't expect to spend money buying tokens just to waste 50 of them on this!!!!

Do you understand you have a logic error here?
If the rating is random then your CM Scout will have 3-4-5-6-7-8-9 random scores.
Since you write he always get low rates then it is not random at all, the opposite :-)
got it ?

[cracicot]

Do you understand you have a logic error here?
If the rating is random then your CM Scout will have 3-4-5-6-7-8-9 random scores.
Since you write he always get low rates then it is not random at all, the opposite :-)
got it ?

I have taken a quick look at morale and have found that nobody knows what the criteria are for assigning numbers for form after the game. What I do know is that your morale will go down daily if your form is 7 or less, for the most part. it will barely go up if you get an 8 and you need a 9 to guarantee that your morale actually goes up.

But that is only one aspect of form. I have not seen anyone, forum member or Nordeus Dev/rep, admit to knowing how form and/or morale actually works yet. AND I can guarantee you that Nordeus will continue to remain silent on how their game works and how to play it better.

I dont think this game is structured/complicated enough for morale/form to be anything but a form of randomness. Think about it: the game engine locks the game 3 mins before it starts so it can produce its matrix of results. During that time it determines what results can happen based on all the numbers presented by both teams. THEY SAY that you can influence the results based on your decisions during the game, whether that happens is up for debate, but regardless, after the game, your form is calculated and presented.

The question after the result is published, is how does the game engine decide which players had good games or bad games. I mentioned this in another post: does it calculate it based on passes completed, shots, goals, assists, etc, or is it just a number it assigns, because most of the time, the form is illogical.

Everyone can say that the GK didnt do enough to warrant a good rating if you win handily, but a GK can still have good form and play well even if he only has 2 shots against him. The whole point is that the GK keeps a clean sheet and if he produces a few good saves, it should be worth at least an 8.

The problem is not the game as much as it is the devs for programming it like this. There is no rhyme or reason for many things in this game that the game engine produces, and form/morale is just one of those things that needs explaining from Nordeus.

EDIT: after re-reading this, I would speculate that the amount of influence that each player has on the game to produce the results determines what form is assigned to each player.

Example: scoring goals/assists and how many times a players name is mentioned, MIGHT give you a favourable form rating more often.

Just a theory.....