Midfield player should have playmaker SA or dribbler SA?

[JanCz]

IMO SA are responsible rather for frequency of plays than their quality. For example, SA "playmaker" means that player will more often get the ball and try to do a key through pass to forwards/wingers. If I'm right, SA are almost useless in comparison to standard allocate points. Player of value 20 without SA will play more flexible; player of the same value with SA will often try to do his "best action" (e.g. shoot from distance), so it's better not to assign SA and spend points on skills. The one and only situation when SA work fine is when your player has a significant advantage over his opponent. SA works then as a slight bonus for actions of that type and your player does it often and (because of advantage in key skills for that action) does it well. You know, AML of v 23 with SA "dribble" playing against DR of v 20 will always be a serious threat.

[rastaman70]

IMO SA are responsible rather for frequency of plays than their quality. For example, SA "playmaker" means that player will more often get the ball and try to do a key through pass to forwards/wingers. If I'm right, SA are almost useless in comparison to standard allocate points. Player of value 20 without SA will play more flexible; player of the same value with SA will often try to do his "best action" (e.g. shoot from distance), so it's better not to assign SA and spend points on skills. The one and only situation when SA work fine is when your player has a significant advantage over his opponent. SA works then as a slight bonus for actions of that type and your player does it often and (because of advantage in key skills for that action) does it well. You know, AML of v 23 with SA "dribble" playing against DR of v 20 will always be a serious threat.

the problem with what you say is that you dont see the player make all these moves, meaning the commentary is not telling you every move this player makes, it sporadically gives you comments on things it views as important or just to give you an update...apparently.

the SA is worthless sometimes. think about it. you have a 4* MC with freekick. according to the nordeus, he plays as a 5* MC when he takes a freekick, so I would translate that into adding 15 pts to his skill. If that is the case, then almost ANY 5* MC without freekick will be just as good. so what I am saying is that the SA is worthless in alot of cases.

just buy your guy with SA or dont bother. i see many successful teams with hardly any players with SA. they really dont matter.