Printable View
I came 8th in the league but had identical points, goals scored and goals against as the team in 7th! So why he get promoted and into the champions league and I stay 8th???!
My team name is: Spank City in case admin want to check this bug out?
Thanks
maybe you lost direct duels vs him?
That's what I thought too but I drew both games with the team in 7th. 0-0 at home and 2-2 away.
We should of had a play off game or both get promoted as joint 7th?
I guess its only goal difference/goals scored the; direct duels are ignored and its a coinflip who is promoted. Bad luck for you
This is the problem. We both scored the exact same goals and both let in the exact same goals. We have identical records. Same points and everything... There is no differences.... T11 should promote us both or have a play off game...
well. . should have taken a picture
I have taken a screen picture but don't know how to upload it on here....
first the team that are 7th won`t be in champions league as it the top 4 that go into that and second not a clue but staying down can be a blessing as you will have stronger team for your level so can aim for top 4 finish if you want champions league football
Good point about being stronger for not going up but it's the principle now as I would like T11 to explain what the reason is for keeping me down even though I had the exact stats as 7th place. I also missed out in £40 million prize cash!
Well someone had to stay down, right? It's either you or him... and it happened to be you unfortunately. I am assuming it's just based on random luck if everything is the same.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kristian Farrant
But just post a picture, upload it here via photobucket or tinypic. Just copy the BB code here
don`t quote me one this until the league comes up as it will say rules on there but if i`m not mistaken if two teams are the same then they will play a one of match to decide who finishes where ? so you may played a one of without realizing or knowing and unfortunately there`s no way of knowing as we can`t see last season games :) ??
I don't know how to upload a pic via BB code. Can I email it to you and can you upload it on her for me please?
Do you see the icon about 4 spaces away from the smiley face? It's a picture of a tree. Click on it and then you can upload your picture hereQuote:
Originally Posted by Kristian Farrant
Attachment 14038
Thank you Dv8r, can you see this image now? I just realised the team in 9th is also the SAME as my (8th) and the team in 7th!!
Also, Spornybol, I know I came 8th, because I got a mail in my in game mail box saying "you came 8th and did not get promoted... bla bla bla..".... check out the league attached?
if it was a one of game it would have been played yesterday but as said won`t know till league comes up on tuesday or MK replies tomorrow if he`s read this thread to confirmQuote:
Originally Posted by Kristian Farrant
Thanks spornybol .... did you notice the 9th placed team has the same stats as me (8th) and the team in 7th, so in fact, there are THREE teams on the same, so no one off game could have been played for all of us three do you think?? :confused:
Now there are THREE teams on identical stats.... How did T11 make 2 of us miss out on promotion??
Can a mod or admin reply please??
Thank you
don`t think mods can answer this one as they actually work behind the scene but hopefully MDKII will be around at some point to clarify
I have no answer, I am extremely curious, though. Hopefully MDKII can enlighten us all. :D
Really don't know why your not seeing this as a good thing? This year you will probably crack on and get a champs league spot. Yeh you didn't get the prize money for coming 8th but you don't need it (unless you need to replace players who have retired)
That is true herdo I should do well this season now, but I am very curious like Cat is too :) how they came to the decision of who came 7th out of us three identical teams, it is a very interesting point now. And that £40mill would have been handy.... Better in my bank than the other team! ;)
Who is MKDII? Can someone PM them to read and reply please? :)
I bet they have already but have no answers.... Lol ;)
i pm`d MDK this morning so hopefully will get a reply and he`s an adminQuote:
Originally Posted by Kristian Farrant
Thanks spornybol - no joy yet :(
Well, that means he has had two messages, unfortunate accidental mail bomb to MDKII. He did reply that he is looking into it, please give him some time, ok?
Thanks cat too!
I was hoping to get it resolved before the league starts tomorrow, but I can appreciate it can take some time :)
Thanks again all for your time and replies - appreciated :)
To be honest I'm pretty disapointed about not getting a reply from MDK or any one explaining the reason, my post has been on here for 3 days! :(
It shouldn't take this long to review my situation and drolly to my question :(
Now I've started my new season in league level 9 with no prize cash for also "coming joint 7th".... Come on MDK please respond??
I've also PMd Him but without a reply.... I think the lack of response on here from him (them) is disgusting.... It shouldn't take long for them to review my question.... Why taking them 4 days and still no reply??? Ffs
How long does he need?....Quote:
Originally Posted by Cat Harrison
That I do not know, I haven't got a reply yet either. I will PM him tomorrow if still no answer, ok?
I apologize for the delayed reply. I was looking into the issue yesterday and trying to find out what exactly had happened.
At the moment, if absolutely all stats are identical at the end of the season, it is determined randomly who won. This is probably what has happened on your end. We realize however that this isn't a fair solution, so we'll be making changes to it so there isn't such a random factor in play. I am sorry that this has cost you your League position.
Thanks, MDKII!
That now makes it two instances in which the information in the rules and prizes is incorrect.
Champions league rules and prizes still says that from the QF onwards, the draw is random (it is not)
and
League rules and prizes says that there is a playoff game to determine ties for championship or qualification to other competition.
Thanks for the reply MDKII, but due to this "system game error" I lose £40 million and promotion...? correct?
Do i get any compensation for this?? as I can appreciate it doesn't happen very often, but the fact it has happened, what do i get out of this balls up made by T11 and no fault of mine?
I spend real cash and a lot of time daily playing this game, and this is how I am treated? :(
It can not be hard to arrange a play off game? (like the rules) but as this it to late to play (due to the lateness of the reply to my email 4 days ago before the new season started) what suggestions can be done, maybe 50 tokens or £40 million for compensation would be a nice goodwill gesture?
8th is better than 7th on this game.
If you don't make the Champions League, then you are better off failing promotion altogether.
I don't agree, I miss out on larger prize cash per game in the higher league per game too, and higher scout players to purchase.Quote:
Originally Posted by July Fourth
Anyway the point is, I should have been either promoted or had a play off game, but I had neighther. Sooooo what is T11 going to do to compensate me and my team please?
I would suggest PMing MDKII if you want an answer to that, as I don't believe it's a question the Forum can answer with any authority.
Thanks Cat, I did PM him 4 hours ago, so I will wait to see if he replies.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cat Harrison
But at the end of the day it's T11s fault, so why shouldn't the forum and everyone know about this and if compensation is given out like it should, then it's a good thing for T11, as it shows they are willing to accept the mistake and keep the players playing knowing they will be looked after...
I've sent you a response. Like I've said, in these sort of scenarios, please contact Nordeus Support.
it is not totally random if you have the same stats. the one who play the last match the first will be the leader (ie: the 1st one archive this stat, the home team if there is a match between the 2). So it means at the 28th days. try to play your game as soon as possible.
of course, it's not fair but you need to live with it before Nordeus do smth for you
