Wtf!!!!

[Playsmartpeople]

then what is the star rating for if it does not give measure of how good the player is?

well, here is the comparison my friend :

Both this players are attacker.

-Player A,

Defense =22
Attack =25
Physical =23

-Player B,

Defense=15
Attack =30
Physical =25

since they dont need defense, so player B will perform better than player A overall.

All around 6* player and Specialize 6* player is a different thing. and dont forget about whether or not they have special ability with them.