Cup defeats but I'm still trying to understand how??

[Sully]

Has anyone from Top Eleven ever come out and explained these strange results and how terrible tactics win games like this? I've been reading this forum for a few weeks now without posting but I noticed there has been a few complaints like this without any explanation from Top Eleven.

In real life that teams tactics would lose so many goals!

[pita_norf]

Thanks for the comments guys. I must say my faith in the game and the validity of the game engine has taken a knock. I've just seen my CL draw and the player only has the bare minimum players and his squad selection is incomplete - could be an inactive player but if the same happens again I think I will give up on this game for good.