Goalkeeper brainteaser

[Gat Manar]

So question is: what GK would you keep in your starting 11 (btw I've never seen any of my defenders with a rating under 6) ?

why all this attention to rates? rates are random... when a player don't touch the ball it's rate is low. try to play on the left wing and check the rate of players on the right.
So.. you gk don't see the ball in a match? rate is low. Your gk touch the ball often, is rate is high.

[brunom14]

why all this attention to rates? rates are random... when a player don't touch the ball it's rate is low. try to play on the left wing and check the rate of players on the right.
So.. you gk don't see the ball in a match? rate is low. Your gk touch the ball often, is rate is high.

I know a lot of things are random but, in the end, you need to make decisions based on something... So one will say rating is crap, the other one will say morale has no influence, or condition, or formation, or, or, or, or... which is probably true. But then, what ?