How is this realistic???

[jebenko]

Here you can see both of our formations. I had 4-3-3 wide and he had 3-5-2.
My team mentality was normal, focus passing mixed, pressing style whole pitch, passing normal, passing long, marking zonal.
And my whole team is 4 stars and one player is 5 star. best player 21, gk 19, 3 players 18 and all other 17.