Which player should I choose?

[t11_fan]

trust me ... those stupid skills is not that important aside from freekick and corners

And freekick and corners are most useful when offensive player has them. My favourite combination is ST corner specialist.
I had few players like this, they are amazing, 25+ league assists per season.
Don't add your defender skill points on attack skills. Don't add skill points on defensive skill for offensive players (AM, ST)

If you have tokens to buy scouts, then I suggest you to buy ONLY mildfielders. The best you can find is MC quallity x4/x9, age under 25.
Otherwise buy nordgens and give them proper training, just like this one...