The problem? The problem is that they introduced so much affirmative action, randomness that in 2 years you'll have no one playing this anymore.
Winning team players and ratings:
6 stars: 0
5 stars: 1
4 stars: 7
3 stars: 3
8 points: 1
7 points: 7
6 points: 3
Losing team players and ratings:
6 stars: 2
5 stars: 7
4 stars: 2
3 stars: 0
8 points: 3
7 points: 6
6 points: 2
Conclusion
Logic: 0
Sense: 0
Psychological Reward: -9
Possibility of dedicated player spending money in the future: -9