Can you provide a screenshot of such a player's skills?

One thing I have worked on, since the last season, has been balancing skills. For instance, I won't take on a striker who doesn't have good defensive skills. Then, a defender must have good attacking skills because attacking includes passing. If there is a gap, then I make sure to attribute newly earned skill points to adjust.

I am convinced that good balance makes your players better and more reliable overall. That does not guarantee results, but I am sure it helps.