Mythbusters of top eleven

[Toxcatl]

I'm just going to leave this here.

[Gert Funck]

I'm just going to leave this here.

A very vague answer.

[Toxcatl]

A very vague answer.

You think the answer is useless? I disagree. It has been confirmed that height, weight and leg are not purely decorative parameters like captaincy. And that their influence is not big... OK, we knew this =]
But it worth something anyway, any piece of information is valuable. For example, if you're chosing a player to train Aerial def, choose the tallest defender.

[Perry Sih]

A very vague answer.

Dude, there can easily be a dozen factors that are included in calculations. Think about in real life, would height be one of the most important factors for determining if a football player is good? Of course not. But does height matter? Sure, in some situations. Is what I'm trying to say vague? Hell no! It's the truth.

[Gert Funck]

Sounds like the person that answers is unsure how the game works!

Ok on the one hand feet, height and weight has a little influence.
Ok, that is fine by me if it was true.

On the other hand, you should NOT look at this when selecting a player. What? So it doesn't matter?

Vague and uncertain answer. Either the engine is so secret or they will not reviel what does not count in the pool of the roll dice.

So sorry no I don't add any value to such a vague answer

[Toxcatl]

Either the engine is so secret or they will not reviel what does not count in the pool of the roll dice.

Of course it is a secret!
The question wasn't about exact formulas and percentages, no one would give us that. It was "do they matter in some way?", and the answer was pretty clear: yes, they do. As a cherry on top, they don't matter very much, not enought for deciding to buy a player or not. There're more important factors you should consider.
Some people suspected that height and weight don't matter at all, so that was unclear. Now we know for sure and can speculate on how exactly they matter. I bet, height matters when Heading is in check, so it's probably a good idea to train Aerial Defender to the tallest defender in your team.

[pcmacdaniel]

I'm just going to leave this here.

I built my entire team around the premise that height matters. Niko talked me out of it, but quality is high enough currently that it'll be a few seasons before I need replacements. All three St's are at least 193 cm, and all the DC's are at least 190 cm.