On overall, none of them are worth it. But if I had to get one in-between those three players, it would be the third one (3rd P > 1st P > 2ndP); the special ability of the 2nd player lowers its desirability. Based on this list only, 3rd P > Scout List STs >1st P >2nd P. Would I buy any of them if I don't intend to buy from the scouts' list? No. So, briefly, this option is like an added option for scout's-list users.