Advice for first scout

[Nicky]

Finally this morning the scout list has been updated!
There are a couple of good players and but want to buy just one, waiting for a good goalie.

They are:

GK, age 23, one2one, 6*39
MC, age 23, playmaker, 6*39

In my roster I have:

GK, age 24, 5*31
GK, age 25, 3*21
MC, age 22, free kick 4*26
MC, age 23, dribbling 4*27
MC, age 25, penalties 4*27
MC, age 32, free kick 4*29

Would you suggest who should I buy?

Thanks