yes but there are many factors that only the manager (you) knows.I think you are not aware of the depth of this question.
Which of them are fast trainers ?
Are they good performers ?
Have any extra positions or sa ?
What is their age ?
What are your plans for this and the next season ?
What are your resources ? (token/ packs/ game money )
Without those info, every opinion will be objective (judging from our teams and tactics which is very possible to be different than yours).