The % calculation is for your whole squad, not just the 14 you have picked in the team.
If you want to manipulate the draw then you need to get rid of high star players, not just move them out of the top 14
Here's an example of my full squad at the end of last season after I'd sold off 8 five star players, this is all I was left with
Click image for larger version.  Name: Lastday14oct.jpg  Views: 129  Size: 78.6 KB  ID: 90151