This is a bug. It has been mentioned a few times and has happened to me too a few times, once in a SL semi 2nd leg when I needed 1 goal.
I believe the result is fixed too. You just know it’s going to happen, suddenly that progress bar shoots across and a few moments later there is a penalty or a Red Card coming. You concede in the first minute or you have a Red Card in first 4 minutes and you know that whatever you do, you’re destined to lose. His GK will get a 9+ rating and have the match of his life. You just have to roll with it when that happens.