Scout GK where is his form???

Guys,

Anyone also had a scout GK of 122% and plays always different.

1 game he got an 10 the next match a 6 ..

After that an 8 again and so on......


What to do with him more training or bench him?

He has suffered many goals ??

Maybe the opponent's performance interferes. Opponents who kick more at the goal force their goalkeeper to make more defenses and other times the opponents will kick less to the goal, making then its goalkeeper tries less.

Sorry at least bad English, I'm Brazilian XD

My experience tells me that the GK are unreliable no matter what skills they have or SA. One game they have a 9 rating, the next a 5 rating. So I would say that a 4* GK will perform the same as a 7* because it all depends on your opponent and what the game engine decides to throw at you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dave1311

My experience tells me that the GK are unreliable no matter what skills they have or SA. One game they have a 9 rating, the next a 5 rating. So I would say that a 4* GK will perform the same as a 7* because it all depends on your opponent and what the game engine decides to throw at you.

---

So you have the same feeling.

Gk is more cosmetic... I think I better buy a good DC than a good GK

Depends upon your defenders. If your defense performs then your goalie will do good. But sometimes, the goalie alone performs beyond all expectations. But I guess defenders performance matters and is proportional to how your goalie performs

Sent from my Mi A1 using Tapatalk

Dave nails it. I have won trebles with a simple 5 star GK, they don't have any real value in TE. Defenders are also treated unfairly by the engine, TE seem to care only about attackers and goals. It is crazy to have a fullback with only 1 or 2 assists all season despite giving great performances.

That is true well I am a defense minded coach and go for counters. Both my accounts are performing well goona surely win the league in both my accounts won the cup in both accounts, and in the other I am in the finale of the champions league. The only downside is I had to face against higher lvl and stronger players & still winning it. And yes my defenders are doing really good all are 100% + and yes the GK seems to do better in accordance with my defenders

Sent from my Mi A1 using Tapatalk

There are some players that definitely play like that (regardless of position), with ratings like 9-6-8-6-9-5-8. Up one game and down the next. I avoid those players if at possible. There's nothing you can do to train them, consistency seems to be one of those hidden elements of the game engine

I know this is not the place but, any idea why I can't watch videos from my mobile data since the update??? Works well with WiFi but with my mobile data it never works. Just keep loading???

Sent from my Mi A1 using Tapatalk

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ludo_Mansio

There are some players that definitely play like that (regardless of position), with ratings like 9-6-8-6-9-5-8. Up one game and down the next. I avoid those players if at possible. There's nothing you can do to train them, consistency seems to be one of those hidden elements of the game engine

---

I was going to say something similar. Isn't the Gk... are what I call the contributive players.
Key player- appear 90% matches doing something good
contributive - can do "something good" 1 match yes, 1 no so ratings look like 6-8-6-8-6 . These can have a positive impact or a bad one, ex. assisting time to time, or been aggressive, losing balls etc.
neutral - dont appear in the old simulation with comments -so we don't see their name- but he can have a impact in the players arround, for good or bad.

The GK can't be neutral, because if Im right, we see him in the 100% of matches, but can perform in a random way, or be a key player, been determinant in some way (ex. I had my Gk in FKs scoring a good amount of them, and stopping PKs often)....

So.... all isn't black or white, ofc. a scorer have more attention than a DC, but it's interesting see the differances between x and y player and realize that at some point, any position can be determinant.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ludo_Mansio

There are some players that definitely play like that (regardless of position), with ratings like 9-6-8-6-9-5-8. Up one game and down the next. I avoid those players if at possible. There's nothing you can do to train them, consistency seems to be one of those hidden elements of the game engine

---

I was going to say something similar. Isn't the Gk... are what I call the contributive players.
Key player- appear 90% matches doing something good
contributive - can do "something good" 1 match yes, 1 no so ratings look like 6-8-6-8-6 . These can have a positive impact or a bad one, ex. assisting time to time, or been aggressive, losing balls etc.
neutral - dont appear in the old simulation with comments -so we don't see their name- but he can have a impact in the players arround, for good or bad.

The GK can't be neutral, because if Im right, we see him in the 100% of matches, but can perform in a random way, or be a key player, been determinant in some way (ex. I had my Gk in FKs scoring a good amount of them, and stopping PKs often)....

So.... all isn't black or white, ofc. a scorer have more attention than a DC, but it's interesting see the differances between x and y player and realize that at some point, any position can be determinant.