Quote Originally Posted by Morgan O'Bree View Post
Every weird result you see or even sniff become "omfg game engine is **** see this". Wtf.
Nonsense. The guy is second place with this left flank formation. He has beaten everyone in the league except me and the one in the pics with this formation. That is 8 wins and a draw with that stupid formation.

Your take on both games, although it has logic, is flawed in that you forget to factor in the NGE. Sometimes the games just dont make sense and THAT is my point. You can pick any formation in the world and sometimes it will win, no matter how unlikely.

I watch ALOT of games and pay attention to the "odd" ones, so I feel I can point out ones that should not happen. It would be so easy to say the arrow formation should lose to all formations that cover the middle and exploit the lack of pay on the wings. This guys left flank attack should have done much better and at least scored a goal. That arrow formation is not as good as the narrow diamond, IMHO.

Add all the commentary you want, I appreciate the feedback and take it into account, but sometimes these odd formations defy explanation.