At £5 a ticket for a Level 1 player you have set the price way too high, drop the price to £3 and see what happens
I will give it a shot but I do get more fans than what my club says also. I have a fan base of around 550 but get nearly 800 watching my game. Alao to a previous comment I i win nearly every game bar 3 of them. Anyway I will lower price and report back thanks.