Well in my league, against the competition I have left now. According to team ratings im way ahead, im on 17 and they are around 13-14.
I have put attack mentality and have given my MC's and ST's the red arrow. My MC's are of 19 quality while a ST is 21, and a 19.
I used to tick the force counterattacks till I found out It was not me doing the counterattacks it was forcing the other team to do one.

I have also noticed, my best striker(21) misses one on one opportunities alot and most of the time passes the ball, even on a one on one opportunity for some reason. I have distributed the stats equally too, I don't know whats up, the 2nd striker does most of the goals or my MC's