Any formation could beat another.. as we said many times, there's no best formation and i personally would never sugest to play counter formation based on what you opponent is playing.. I would sugest you to make a formation and stick to it untill it works- don't change anything if it's winning..
Let other teams addapt to your style and don't play it the other way around, that's why i called this "top 10 formations" and not "top 10 counter formations"
Anyhow.. if you can rotate your team however you like without losing any of your good performing players.. hardly impossible to achieve as there's always some players that perform better than others.. use 4-1-4-1 Defensive, it's the 2nd listed formation on 1st page..