The new star system (and the negotiation list)

Experiment - Ronaldo
1) Ronaldo 5* old
Attachment 63764

2) Ronaldo 5* new
Attachment 63765

3) Ronaldo 6* old
Attachment 63766

4) Ronaldo 6* new
Attachment 63767

1) Ronaldo is a new player (fast trainer) I bought. It looks with the old version that he needs 13 sp for being a 6*

2) But as we see in the new version, it's not like this.
He has 113,4 + 114,5 + 115,5 >> 113,4 + 115 + 115 >> 8 (old) sp
This happening because there is a different "translation" from % quality to numbers quality (1 sp isn't exactly 4 new sp, it's from 1 to 4).

3) When I gave 8 (old) sp after some training, Ronaldo became a 6* player even if it looks like he still missing 5 sp to be a 6* player.

4) That's because in the new version, he has 113,4 + 116,1 + 115,5 >> (113,4 +1,1 +0,5) + 115 + 115 >> 115 + 115 + 115

So, what we do when we want to set a player to nego list ?
We observe how many old sp he needs but from the mask of the version.
Also, we must be very careful because in the new version, we can't see the blue bar of progress so sometimes instead of 1 sp, we can get 2 sp. Also because 1 sp from the old training, can be "translated" in a different way.

Experiment - Batistuta
Attachment 63769

46 + 59 + 58 > (46+4+3) +55 +55 >53 +55 +55 10 sp missing for 6* player with the old system

Attachment 63770
46,1 +59,4 +58,2 > (46,1 +4,4 +3,2) +55 +55 >53,7 + 55 +55 1,3 missing or else 5 or 6 sp with the new system

Attachment 63771
giving 5 old sp
46 +60 +58 > (46 +5 +3) +55 +55 > 54 +55 +55 5sp missing

Attachment 63772
46,1 +60,4 + 58,2 > (46,1 +5,4 +3,2) +55 +55 > 54,7 +55 +55 0,3 missing
So, here is a question. Maybe my player is already in nego list ?
The correct one should be 54,8 +55 + 55 but how can I give him 0,1 ?

let's try to give 1 old sp

Attachment 63773
He got his 6*
46 + 60,2 + 58 > (46+5,2 +3) +55 +55 > 54,2 +55 +55 and it's 4 more sp with the old version

Now it's
Attachment 63774
46,1 +60,6 + 58,2 > (46,1 +5,6 +3,2) > 54,9 + 55 +55 and that gives a a 6*

I tried to read Niko's illustration but I cannot follow because I lack knowledge on new version. I surprised to know that the quality value in new system is different with those in old version because it is translated from percentage back to value. Yesterday, I logon new version to study meaning of percentage but I failed. I end my study, and wait for someone's further explanation I will understand.

Hey cookiz I finally managed to set my player in negotiation list.
Two things to say
1) With the old version it's almost impossible to do that because the calculation is little different.
2) You don't have to look at %

Ok, let's go

This is my player Zagallo

Z1
Attachment 63808
Has 108 +119 +116,4 >> (108+4+1,4) +115 +115 >>113,4 +115 +115
With the old version he wants 1,4 q, to be 1sp from 6* .
1 sp is 0,2 q so he wants 7 sp to be in the list.

Z2
Attachment 63809
With the new version, as we see in the picture, first of all we forget % numbers.
I see only the numbers in parenthesis ()
Here we see that it's different from the old version. This is (I think) from the wrong "translation" , the rounding of the digits.
So
108,1 +119,1 +116,5 >> (108,1 +4,1 +1,5) + 115 +115 >> 113,7 +115 +115
Here it looks he needs 5 (or 6) sp

Z3
Attachment 63812
So, I go to the old version and do some training for 5 sp

Z4
Attachment 63813
Back in the new version and here I can see
108,1 +120,1 +116,5 >> (108,1 +5,1 +1,5) +115 +115 >> 114,7 +115 +115.
It needs 0,3 for the next star. At that point, I was waiting , maybe that 0,3 was like 1 sp of the old version.
* just to be sure, wait for a day or so, at that point.
I had no offers so I started some training with the new version.
I did light training, the first drill of M&P, the "warm up".
After some of those training (only to that player), he got a 0,1 q so now he is 0,2 from the next star as it was in the old version

Z5
Attachment 63814
My player is in nego list now

So, after a while, some amazing offers started coming :o

Z6
Attachment 63815

So, as I understand now, we must observe the quality values as shown in new version to determine if they are close to nego list or next star.

yes, but as it hard to find exactly the sp progress with the new training, better to gather the demanded sp from the old one.
(or at least it's looks easier to me).
After that of course, we must start an extra position or sa as priority for the gaining (if we want to use our player in the games).
Also remember that when we click those buttons (extra role or sa) , we 're setting the priority.

This is my player Thamnidis and I had a post about him in first page, #10 - as a player in nego list.

After two seasons, now Thamnidis is 27 y.o.. I had to use him in the first two games of the Cup as I didn't have enough players (defenders actually).
Playing those games, he got this 0,2 sp and he became a 75Q player - so he is out of the nego list now.
Meantime, I had some gifts sp for him.
His special ability is active so the earning sp should go there and not in quality but I guess this is a bug of the game (is it ? :o )
So, if you have a good offer, don't wait too much to give your player.
Attachment 65140


* that's not relative, but as I upload the photo, you can see that his morale was zero when I used him (after staying for so long time in the bench) but still he got a 7,3 and 8,3 in those two games.
Just another confirmation that low morale doesn't many times doesn't affect the performance of the player - save your blues :o

Answers in RED

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cookizzz

Thanks for your detail illustration. I have not yet fully understand. Kindly clarify the followings:

1) For your example above, if the player is trained under new version and is improved, the improvement will be added to SA. New star will not be immediately added, because the sp accumulated for SA is not calculated for adding star, isn't it? YES IT IS !!!

2) For same example but assume there is no sp accumulated for SA. When 1 sp is assigned to attack/defense/P&M, new star may be added. But it is also possible that new star will not be added until 2nd, 3rd, 4th or even 5th sp are assigned. So we are not completely certain about the trigger point, right? If no SA opened, training remains classical and evolving too. If SA is opened and at 0, in my exemple you only have to release the 16 SP (=3.2 pts) to know what could happen !

3) If I train players with old version and create some sp for my players, a new star will not be suddenly added to these players until I assign sp, will it? YES... if you only play on OLD VERSION. Otherwise NO if you train them on OLD VERSION to earn SP and then play on NEW VERSION, Nordeus will add automatically SP first on SA second on player directly (and will add SA points to global calculation that will let your player get the new star even if yet at 4 or 9%).

Thanks. I am still curious about this.

---