It's good that you won, but next time I'd stay at normal if you take the lead and have good possession. I'd only change to attacking if you went behind, and don't use extreme attacking/defending as they aren't very good tactics. You might have won by more than 2-1.
I beat 3W-2N(MC)-3W(AM)-2 by using 4-1-4-1 with short passing, attack down both flanks, no counter, no offside, normal tacking, normal mentality. My team was stronger, but I was away and opponent was watching the game, so a tough match on paper - Result was 5-2 to me.
So 4-4-2 classic beats 4-2N(MC)-3W(AM)-1 and 4-1-4-1 beats 3W-2N(MC)-3W(AM)-2. Both using same orders (as mentioned above).