--- --- ST. --- ---
--- --- AMC --- ---
ML^ --- MC. --- MR^
--- --- DMCv--- ---
DL. DC. --- DC. DR.
--- --- GK. --- ---
My previous two seasons, I ran a 4-4D-2 by default, using only a red forward arrow on the DMC. My second formation was the 4-5V-1 using a blue defensive arrow on the DMC and red forward arrows on the DL/DR. My point is, it sounds like the formation and tactics are right with your current squad, just change the arrows