Wow, what did you do the first match, formation and tactics?

I wouldn't safely assume he'll focus down flanks, not that it changes much either way.

I'll beat him 4411 normal, high, long, mixed/ right flank, counters try both on and off; low, zonal, normal, might try offside trap. Either your tactics were a mismatch for his or he got you with counter attacks.

Share more info from match 1 for better advice. Stats page, ratings, formation and tactics...