Quote Originally Posted by cracicot View Post
no, its a troll win. 5* vs 2*, 4-4-2 vs 4-3W-1-2. the odds are with the 5* team in this case and they should have won. Orders dont have much to do with this case, unless the 58 team went hard defending with blue stars on everyone. The quality of the 5* team should have at least scored a goal.

Havent we already established that rating mean nothing at all? Just to humour you, his DC gets a 9 and MoM and a 2* team keeps a 5* team off the scoreboard because of one person - a 1* DC? A troll win.
His entire team may be 2*, but his lineup was averaged at least 2,8+ which isn't terrible. Again, I don't doubt that it's an unlikely result, but the only stats we have from that match is formation (without underlying tactics) and quality. There are far more factors than these 2 that can mess up the result. 5* should not have to beat 3* in *all* situations. Perhaps he should have in this case, but unless there are more stats on the other factors, you can never say for sure if it's a troll win.