Mine's had a nightmare in the ratings this season. He's had a 3, a 4 and, in the last 5 league matches, straight 5s (although we have not conceded a goal in those) and still only 3 GA in the league. He's not caught anything much at corners because when winning we've not given many up.
Last year was peachy.
So I'm not giving him up because 1 stat says 1 thing and another says different. But first time he drops a clanger its *punt*. Career over.
But now I'm thinking of giving him kick duties just to try to improve the stats.