Height of a player as criterion

[nikolgiorgos]

Hi my friends
I want your advice about which one player to keep for my next season.
Both are nordgens, with the same sa, their stats are similar so their age and gaining ability in training.
For some tactic reasons I must keep only one.
I wonder if the height of the player maybe can be a criterion so to choose the taller one. I didn't see so far any difference between them. They score from shots, not from corner passing (and not from free kicks).
Is also height can make a difference in defending ability of a MC ?

[khris]

I keep the 1st. lol

[Crister]

Hi my friends
I want your advice about which one player to keep for my next season.
Both are nordgens, with the same sa, their stats are similar so their age and gaining ability in training.
For some tactic reasons I must keep only one.
I wonder if the height of the player maybe can be a criterion so to choose the taller one. I didn't see so far any difference between them. They score from shots, not from corner passing (and not from free kicks).
Is also height can make a difference in defending ability of a MC ?

They have the exact weight and height as Ronaldo and Messi. So it is up to you to choose one of them

[mani8005]

I would keep the 2nd one.... he is a scout... has better stats than 1st....

My choice would be 2nd

[nikolgiorgos]

I would keep the 2nd one.... he is a scout... has better stats than 1st....

They don't have much difference in quality. It's about 20-25 skill points and the first one is (for now) faster trainer than the other. He gets about +80 in 3 bars practice match while the short now has +55.
With an extra training and my green packs I can have him in the new season as a scout.

[mani8005]

But more than that... 2nd player form stats r better.... he has 3 mom and gets an avg 7.... me would prefer the 2nd

[nikolgiorgos]

Well, I don't count on rates of MCs much. Usually my MCs have a range of 6-7-8 and it's not steady. Only one year I had a MC that had steady rates of 8 and some 7 or 9 but he had many goals as a free-kick specialist.

[sincity]

Taller MCs tend to do better in the game than shorter ones, but in your case I would keep the second one cause he had more goals, more MOM and more Q

[nikolgiorgos]

Maybe I could use them together in the same next games (because I have other two MC and using rotation) and see who 'll get the highest stats.

[Sven Spel]

Taller MCs tend to do better in the game than shorter ones, but in your case I would keep the second one cause he had more goals, more MOM and more Q

No he have less goals. first guy do one goal every 2 games and 2nd guy do one goal every 4 games.
2nd guy have a little more SP but first one train faster.
A mom with only 7 rating means the team was doing bad, not that he was playing good.
2nd guy also have more 6 rated games.
I would get 2nd guy to Q 59 and then sell him, guess he already have enough SP for that.