Captain, oh my Captain

[Steppenwolf]

Ratings are universal... If a 5* player gets rating 7, in the same game as 6* player he could only get same or better rating, 'cause of better skills, not the opposite...

[nikolgiorgos]

Even Neuer won't get 8 or 9s if he's playing v crap

yes of course, but let's say real football has the t11 logic.
Someone who can't watch on tv (radio,internet) the games and reads in the "Kicker" about the games of German league, then he could think that Neuer (few goals but inactive, with rates of 6-7) it's just a ok GK
or
someone reading the "Marca" about the rates of Iniesta (not many assists or free-kicks, lack of defending abilities) is thinking that he is a pretty average MC

[nikolgiorgos]

Ratings are universal... If a 5* player gets rating 7, in the same game as 6* player he could only get same or better rating, 'cause of better skills, not the opposite...

I understand it, like that if I have a 4* GK who has a 5* oppo ST who scores (in a corner, free-kick, one-to-one ...)
or
he is a 6* GK, the logic says that he is more qualified and it's more possible to save his goal post, but if both fail, the 6* GK will have a bigger penalty in his rate.

[Steppenwolf]

the 6* GK will have a bigger penalty in his rate.

No, he wont... He would get the same rating if he would play exactly the same, but he wont play exactly the same...

[HoofDaddy]

I agree with nik, this is the reason that 6 stars can seem to drop in rating even tho they aer performing the same. As somebody that plays a lot of 2 and 3 star players throughout the season, I would say rating is relative to quality.

[Steppenwolf]

Rating is relative to performance... If a 1* and a 9* would play equally same, bad or good, they would both get the same rating... It's not like, if a 9* would get rating 4 for a bad performance related to his quality, that a 1* would get rating 9 if he would play exactly the same... Same performance would result same ratings, no matter how many starts players have...

[nikolgiorgos]

Rating is relative to performance...

yes, but what exactly is performance ? Playing good, ODT or having result ?
A GK who played good but his team conceded 5 goals ? A ST who played good, got a rate of 7 because he didn't score ?
So far I couldn't find consequence or codification in whole the games of t11 but anyway rates aren't easy thing to real football too.
What about Mario Gomes (of Bayer Munchen) ? When he scored one goal got a 8 ? 2 goals (or some assists) , a 9 ? No goal, a 7 ?
What is his real value ? What about if he didn't play in a team machine like Bayern ?
Just rhetoric questions ...

[nikolgiorgos]

Ok now, back to the subject of the thread. Amane didn't show up to give me some advices for the Captain but my team must goes on.
My team seams that 'll succeed to tank this season



even if it had some hard times




my DC Torosidis playing as GK, is making fantastic saves, my GK Antoniou clears oppo attacks
at least he doesn't assist from the corners (much ).

[nikolgiorgos]

In CH.L. played the first match of the semi final, against a team with this weird formation



Changing my kickers in Corners, Free-kicks, trying to play from the flank with no oppo Def., loosing one-to-one, continually tackling
making oppo GK and defenders, the heroes of the game.
but who can win Nordeus Gods

[Gert Funck]

thats just wrong






I smell a troll